☆ ☆ ☆Star
Wars Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker (2019) – J. J. Abrams
It
is tempting to compare what director J. J. Abrams has delivered in this final instalment
of the Star Wars saga to what could have been – and you would invariably be
disappointed (as many or most viewers were).
Instead, it may be more fruitful to think about the pleasures that the
film does offer. So, if, like me, you
saw the first Star Wars (Episode IV: A New Hope) when you were 9 or 10 years
old, what would you be hoping for now? If you were the director, what would you
include? Abrams (born 1966) probably
found himself exactly in this situation.
So, when he directed Episode VII: The Force Awakens, he set about
recreating the plot of the 1977 film, albeit with new protagonists (Daisy Ridley
as Rey is the new Luke etc.) but also bringing back the original actors from
the first trilogy to play key cameo roles in the new film. I enjoyed that “remake” myself. But now, in his second go at Star Wars, could
Abrams really use the same formula again?
The answer is yes. So, we do see
some older actors returning to reprise their roles (surprises included) and we
get some nods to the past (Luke lifts his x-wing out of the swamp…finally) and
some retreads (what! Another bar with aliens in it?). The Rebels have to fight the Empire/First
Order/Final Order all over again – and guess what? They win. (Sorry for the spoiler). As in the earlier films, generational
conflict is the main subtext – we know that Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) is the son
of Han Solo (Harrison Ford, appearing as a force ghost) and Princess Leia (Carrie
Fisher appearing in footage found on the cutting room floor from Episode VII sadly
repurposed). He’s turned to the dark
side and wants to take Rey with him – but will he prevail? And what about Rey’s own family tree? In this film, we do discover her
lineage. However, and here’s where we
shouldn’t be tempted, not much tension or even exploration is made about these
discoveries and conflicts. They are just
another cog in the plot mechanics, which, it must be said, move swiftly from
one action sequence to another. Truly,
the art direction and special effects look amazing (the wreckage of the
original Death Star!). But, but, but,
the result feels hollow inside (nowhere worse than the nonresponsive Carrie
Fisher slotted into interactions with live actors), with the schematic plot structure
designed only to connect the action sequences and to allow Abrams and his team
to slot in the various required memes (“I’ve got a bad feeling about this”,
death of pivotal characters, etc.). I
say this as someone for whom the original trilogy was something special (and
who mostly skipped the prequel trilogy or forgot about it) – but how would children
growing up now feel about these films? Would they love the new characters played
by Oscar Isaac, John Boyega, and Daisy Ridley, as much as we loved Han, Leia,
and Luke? I suspect not, but hey, it’s Disney’s franchise now and they
certainly know how to make a buck.